Containing a total of 27 stories of which 20 are short stories (some shorter than others), 4 are poems and 3 are something completely different; the book begins with an introduction by Gaiman wherein he presents each individual story, what they represent, how they got created and if and what they've won of awards.
I initially set out to review each and every short fiction and wonder in this book individually. 6 hand written and cramped pages later I realised this would be the world's longest and TL;DR review ever if I didn't limit myself. I will therefore instead tell you of my favourites of which there are quite a few.
A Study in Emerald - Gaiman describes this little masterpiece as "Sherlock Holmes meets the world of Lovecraft" where the rational clashes with the irrational. I absolutely loved it, though I was way too thick to properly get it until it was spelled out for me in the end. Must read A Study in Scarlett to compare!
October in the Chair - A great ghost story wrapped in something entirely different with the months personified and telling tales around a camp fire.
Other People - Very little can be said without spoiling the plot, but this is a truly fantastic, fascinating and utterly creepy tale of endless horror.
Instructions - Mentioning many details from stories read so far throughout the book, Gaiman describes this poem of sorts as instructions as to how to act if one should suddenly find oneself in a fairy tale. I particularly liked the final few lines which conveyed a hauntingly beautiful tone of how childhood differs from life and perception as an adult.
Sunbird - this is a brilliant tale of the members of the epicurean club on the hunt for a new thing to be eaten which leads them on the trail of the Sunbird. But all is not as it would seem, as they are soon to find out.
The Monarch of the Glen - this is the story I've perhaps been the most excited to read and thankfully it didn't let me down. Also known as American Gods #1.5 it's a story about Shadow and what's up to now after all he was put through in Gaiman's novel American Gods. It takes place in Scotland where Shadow is once again pulled into some supernatural shit he didn't ask for but can't seem to leave him alone. It's a brilliant short sequel in my opinion.
All in all I can conclude I'm (still) no fan of poems, but I love just about anything else Gaiman writes. His style is nothing short of amazing. The way he has with words is so very special, the way he's able to construct the most insane yet totally believable scenarios and scenes with far fewer words than you'd think possible.