Velkommen

På bloggen her kan du finde anmeldelser af alt fra fantasy, science fiction, kærlighed, chicklit, YA og NA til historiske romaner, krimier, spændingsbøger, og hvad jeg ellers lige falder over, der ser spændende ud. Herudover er der bl.a. Book Hauls og Kommende Udgivelser, samt Månedlige Opsummeringer. Occasional posts/reviews in English.
~ Iben
Bibliotekar, bogblogger & boganmelder

03/12/2011

Dragonsong by Anne McCaffrey

The Harper Hall #1

----------
Forbidden by her father to indulge in music in any way, a girl on the planet Pern runs away, taking shelter with the planet's fire lizards who, along with her music, opens a new life for her.
----------

I first read the Harper Hall trilogy when I was in my early teens and back then I loved it endlessly, so much in fact that when at a library sale and I came across 3 battered copies I bought them immediately.
I've since them read the books numerous times and even got my hands on the prequel disguised as a sequel, the Masterharper of Pern. I've never read the many books that came before these, but have always intended to.

Very recently Anne McCaffrey passed away and I picked up the first book once more. I was a bit surprised at how much things have changed. Reading with a more critical (and adult) point of view, I found the main character Menolly far too whiny. I'm so used to strong female heroines, that her poor confidence and her lack of ability of stand up for herself took me aback.
I also thought the general language of the book had a very childish tone. Menolly is 15, but is more immature than the 10 year olds from Tamora Pierce's books.

Wikipedia will have you believe that fixed gender roles make Menolly an outcast, as she is unskilled at tasks which are regarded as women's work on Pern and excels in the male-dominated field of music. She chooses to live alone in the dangerously unprotected world outside the Hold instead of allowing her natural talents to be suppressed. Personally I think that's giving the girl far too much credit for an impulse decision, but eh.

However those things aside, the story still held me as firmly as it once did, and I still want a fire lizard of my own.





208 pages / published in 1976
Review by Iben Jakobsen, BoB, 2011

3 comments:

  1. Like you, I loved this book when I was a teen. I've avoided rereading it because I'm afraid I would be disappointed by it now but it's still one of my favorite fantasy book covers!

    ReplyDelete
  2. @Lisa :) It is a gorgeous cover I agree! I don't think rereading the book ruined it for me in anyway, it's just one of those books that work best when you're at a certain age. I used to love the Laura Ingalls books, but have been unable to read them for years (same goes for the LotR books actually)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I've re-read the whole series several times but I was disappointed when I read Dragonsong this time. I think I didn't wait long enough between readings.

    ReplyDelete